Wednesday, October 1, 2014

Integrity: Charlie Strong, Roger Goodell, and the Ethics of Sports

(c) forbes.com


I can’t imagine the challenge facing Coach Charlie Strong.  He was named the head coach at the University of Texas’ prestigious football program in January of this year.  Between the date of his hire and the Longhorns’ first game in late August, he was entrusted with rebuilding the culture of football at one of the most prominent athletic programs in America.  He inherited a program which, while still venerated among major universities, had been through several rough years under the previous coach, Mack Brown, who enjoyed nearly two-decade tenure at UT.

The University’s leadership had the wisdom to allow Coach Strong to bring in his own staff of assistant coaches, offensive and defensive coordinators, and other key leaders from his prior stint at the University of Louisville, effectively giving Strong the reigns to re-cast the culture of football at UT.  One of the things Coach Strong immediately introduced at Texas is a culture of respect, rather than a culture of entitlement.  During spring practice, Coach Strong removed the beloved Longhorn logo from the sides of the players’ helmets, simply stating, “You have to earn those Horns.” 

Strong has built his team’s culture around five key principles, which sound like common sense to many people, but in the world of competitive college athletics (and the larger world of major sports) are major ethical grey areas: honesty, treating women with respect, no drugs, no stealing and no weapons.  You can read a broader description of these values, as well as an interesting conversation between NFL leadership and Coach Strong, at the link below.

http://texas.247sports.com/Bolt/Charlie-Strong-is-the-talk-of-the-NFL-31587363

An article from earlier this year goes into more detail about Coach Strong’s philosophy of football:

http://www.barkingcarnival.com/2014/1/14/5308182/culture-change-at-texas

As the first article points out, the NFL is deeply concerned with learning these five core values because all of them have become issues for several of the leagues’ high-profile players during the last few months.  I think it’s clear why the NFL’s leadership – including their commissioner, Roger Goodell – sought out Coach Strong’s counsel.

Coach Strong – and the team he leads – has integrity.

Despite all of the pressure to just make the team a winner, Coach Strong has taken his five core values to the very heart of the Longhorn football program, and it has been costly to do so.  He and his team have integrity because their values are not merely lip-service; they are real, costly standards for their whole team to abide by.  Nine players have been dismissed from the team during Strong’s tenure for violating these five core values.  Some of the dismissals were starters,  and some were backup players.  Regardless, the on-field results of losing that talent have led to a 2-2 record and lackluster performances against competitive opponents like UCLA and BYU.

Texas’ alumni, fans, and administration want a winning team.  So why support such a bold move by Coach Strong?  Because he’s teaching his team how to play and live with integrity.  Betraying convictions and core values in any family, organization, or relationship does not lead to healthy outcomes in the long run.  Coach Strong wants his players to see this reality before it collides with them after they graduate or – under even greater ethical scrutiny - jump into the NFL.  The young men and coaches he’s responsible for leading are learning that being consistent with the five core values will be costly in the short term.  Buying into these values is a good experience of real life for these players, many of whom are stuffed like a Thanksgiving turkey with elevated ego and endless praise.  Theirs is a precarious position, and Coach Strong is interested in helping them succeed beyond their time in burnt orange and white.


Coach Strong and his staff are helping young men – gifted, talented young men – learn how to navigate real life and be a blessing to the communities around them, not just by putting points on the board but by living out an ethic that is about more than football.  I find it highly appropriate and satisfying that the more “mature” expression of football – the NFL – is taking lessons from the kid brother in college.

No comments:

Post a Comment